10 Best Waterproof Eyeliners

The Rimmel London Soft Kohl Smudge-proof Eyeliner Pencil in Jet Black is a popular choice for those seeking intense color and a smudge-proof finish in their eyeliner. Its soft, blendable formula makes it ideal for achieving a smoky look, and it offers full coverage with a satin finish that is also paraben-free. The eyeliner is designed to last up to 12 hours, providing a long-wear solution that is resistant to stains and fading.

This makes it suitable for a full day without much need for touch-ups, which is a significant advantage for those who need longevity. The pencil form allows for precise application, although some users might prefer a liquid or gel for even sharper lines. While the eyeliner is promoted as smudge-proof, users should note that being a pencil format, it might not be as waterproof as gel or liquid options, which could be a consideration in very moist conditions.

On the plus side, the ease of removal is a benefit, ensuring that it can be taken off without much hassle at the end of the day. Dermatologist and ophthalmologist testing add an extra layer of comfort for those concerned about skin and eye sensitivity. It's a strong contender for anyone looking for an easy-to-use, bold eyeliner that fits well into daily makeup routines, particularly for those who appreciate a softer look and want to avoid harsh chemicals like parabens.

The Rimmel London Scandaleyes Exaggerate Eye Definer in Intense Black offers a rich color payoff that delivers a high-impact look, making it an excellent choice for those who love bold and dramatic eye makeup. Its ultra-creamy texture ensures effortless application, and the retractable automatic tip is convenient for storage and easy use without needing a sharpener.

As a waterproof and smudge-proof eyeliner, it meets the expectation for longevity, lasting up to 24 hours without transferring or smudging, which is a significant advantage for busy individuals or those with long days. Applying it on the waterline further enhances its versatility for creating bold lines, making it suitable for various eye makeup styles. The pigmentation is impressive, providing full coverage with a metallic finish that stands out.

One potential drawback is its ease of removal; while its long-lasting formula is beneficial for wear, it may require a more robust makeup remover to be fully removed. This product is best suited for people seeking a durable, highly pigmented eyeliner that can withstand water and smudging, ideal for both everyday wear and special occasions. Its gluten-free formula and ease of application make it accessible and user-friendly, although care should be taken when removing it to avoid any discomfort.

The NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner is a robust choice for those seeking a waterproof eyeliner, particularly if long-lasting wear is a priority. Its up to 24-hour longevity ensures that your makeup remains intact during long days or nights out, reducing the need for touch-ups. One of its standout features is the intensely pigmented formula, available in six vivid shades, which offers full coverage and a bold matte finish. As a vegan and cruelty-free product, it appeals to consumers who prioritize ethical beauty choices.

The brush tip applicator is designed to provide precision, making it suitable for both beginners and experienced users. By adjusting the pressure and angle, you can achieve anything from a fine line to a dramatic wing, which adds versatility to your makeup routine. Its slender design helps follow the natural curve of your eye effortlessly.

While the waterproof and smudge-proof claims are appealing, some users may find that removing the eyeliner can be slightly challenging, especially without a good makeup remover. This could be a minor inconvenience for those who prefer products that are easy to remove. This eyeliner is ideal for anyone looking to make a bold impact with their eye makeup, whether for everyday wear or special occasions. Its highly pigmented and flexible application make it a reliable addition to any makeup kit, although be prepared to spend a bit more time on removal.